Samsung Galaxy Tablet Review
I bought this for my 9 year old daughter. I played with the tablet for a couple days before I gave it to her.
For comparison: I've had an iPad 2 for 8 months now. I also have a Samsung Galaxy phone and I hate my Galaxy phone! The picture is pretty, but it has all sorts of random glitches. Maybe only 2 to 3 glitches per week but its annoying.
My first impression of the Galaxy tab: The picture quality was incredible. Better than my iPad 2. It's brighter and more colorful but Samsung always has great displays. The tablet seemed slow transitioning from one screen to the next. I restarted it and everything sped back up. I've (my daughter) had the tablet for about 6 weeks now without any issues.
Android Honeycomb was very intimidating for me at first (yes I was a noob). There were way too many options! This made me like my iPad 2 and IOS software that much more - due to the simplicity of Apple. After playing with the Galaxy Tab and Honeycomb for 20 minutes, I realized I wanted to get rid of my iPad 2 and get a Galaxy Tab. The tab is awesome! Android Honeycomb really is incredible. I can't wait till I can install the Samsung Ice Cream Sandwich upgrade on the tab (I'm not into the rom's).
After I gave my daughter the Galaxy Tab, I picked my iPad 2 up to use it, and the screen seemed very small and square shaped. The screen on the Galaxy is not much bigger than the iPad screen, but it seems like it is. The aspect ratio of the Galaxy must work wonders.
One thing I must say about Apple is everything is smooth. My iPad 2 runs every app with ease. The Galaxy isn't quite as smooth, but honestly, I like the Galaxy better. I haven't tried the iPad 3 yet, but it may be overkill for my purposes.
Example of what I mean by smooth: Screen rotation: Ipad 2: about 1.5 seconds. Galaxy Tab: about 2.5 to 3 seconds - Not a big deal for me but worth noting.
Also, the iPad 2's battery life is a bit longer - I think I get another hour out of the iPad 2 but I had far more apps and widgets running on the Galaxy so that may be why the battery died faster. And I think my iPad 2 charges twice as fast as the Galaxy. I haven't measured it but my iPad charges faster.
In closing; If I had a choice to buy either the Galaxy Tab or the iPad 2 for the exact same price, I wouldn't by either. I personally think Apples is a little overpriced and I don't think anyone should be charging the same amount for similar specs. It's kind of like Nike Shoes in the early 1990's: No other shoe company should have been charging as much money as Nike. It's not that Nike was that much better, or even better at all. It's that Nike was iconic at that time, and they charged accordingly/excessively (Apple is the early 90's Nike). If the Galaxy Tab was $100 less than iPad 2, sold! If I had it to do all over again, I would have a Galaxy Tab for myself today. Instead, I'm watching my daughter play on hers.
Samsung Tablet Review
Samsung Tablet Review
I bought 2 galaxy Tab 10.1's the day it came out. I am admittedly not the biggest fan of Apple products. I try to stay out of their locked down ecosystem as much as possible as I firmly believe that the user should be able to OWN their products and decide for themselves what they do and what they install on it, and I'm not a fan of willingly handing over my freedom to corporatocracy.
That said, I have to compare the galaxy tab to the only other real tablet on the market, the venerable iPad/iPad 2.
Pros:
- Out of the box, the gTab running Android 3.1 has a pretty impressive array of features
- Multitasking is REALLY well done, in fact, vastly superior to most other implementations, including iOS4.x. The only other real contenders would be the HP slate
- Gchat support is top notch. Unlike iOS, where Apple had to create a whole new proprietary marketing buzzword around "facetime," gchat just works. It works with phones, it works with PCs, you can voice and video chat with other Android 3.1 devices, OR with any computer running gchat. BOOM. No need to install anything special, it just works.
- Widgets: Ok, if you've used android before, these are nothing new. If you're coming from something else, they could be the coolest things you've ever used, or meh. But they've become a lot more powerful regardless. You can now resize widgets, and having, for instance, a gmail widget on your desktop simply makes accessing email so much faster and easier than it is on any other device.
- Live wallpapers. I love them, you might not, but it certainly makes my tablet looks so much more lively than the static wallpapers of yesteryear.
- Battery life is stupendous. But pretty much on par with the ipads. If you're coming from an ipad you'll not notice anything new. If you're coming from a netbook or phone, you're going to be in for a shock. The thing just won't die.
- Beautiful screen. Samsung is one of the leaders in screen tech. They didn't disappoint.
- OMFG it's skinny. Yes, skinnier than the ipad 2. That's a freakin' achievement.
- I own both the white and the metallic grey gtabs. The white is visually "prettier" and has a high gloss smooth finish. The metallic grey is matte and has a texture to it. I prefer the way the metallic grey feels in my hands, but if you're all about looks, the white is very nice.
- Stereo speakers. This was actually a surprise for me. It has speakers that flank the left and right sides (when held in landscape mode). This is definitely a step up above the mono sound coming out of the ipad/ipad2. Volume is actually a lot louder than I had expected from such a svelte device.
- Sync. If you use a lot of google apps... you're going to be in a world of joy. After booting up the device, and merely entering my email and password, I had my contacts, my email, my calendar, my apps, all instantly and seamlessly ported over to the tablet. No need to connect to a computer. Even my music (amazon music) and pictures (picasa) were immediately available. Color me impressed. There is no other device that can do this. iOS5 claims to be bringing this kind of seamlessness over to the iOS world, along with Android 2.2 style notifications, but thank you, I have that right now, and it's sweet.
- Flash. This tablet has it. Apple's don't. If your RSS feed is populated by all sorts of flash based content like mine is, then you'll love it. If you regularly visit restaurant sites, you'll love it. If you want to play Empires and Allies on your tablet (albeit super slowly) you can only do it on this.
Cons:
- Apps. There is no getting around this. It's brand new, the Xoom was a complete flop, and so developers haven't really spent much time porting their apps over to tablet sized screens. Android natively handles scaling of apps much better than iOS, but despite that, there are quite a number of apps that could do with some serious rework to make the layouts more appropriate for the larger real-estate. Also, in general, the quality of apps on android hasn't reached the level on iOS, but that appears to be very quickly changing as developers are now making all of their apps multiplatform. Amazon is also a disgrace in this area as their own android apps (kindle, mp3, appstore) could use some rework on tablet screens. I would love for the kindle app to be updated with the amazingly slick page turning that comes on Google Books. Google even provides the code to do if for free... so Amazon, get your ass in gear and implement that.
- Stability. My android phone can go for months without a reboot. Android 2.2/2.3 are rock solid. Android 3.1 is not there yet. It's not terrible, but there will be times where you'll have a wtf moment when the tablet stalls at the lock screen and you can't seem to unlock it for a few moments, or some apps inexplicably force close. I consider it relatively minor since it's pretty infrequent, but it happens far more than it does on my phone. Not sure how it compares against iOS as even when I casually use iOS, apps freeze and quit on me, and I even had the ipad completely lock up requiring the powerbutton to be held down to reset it. But since I don't use iOS on a day to day basis, I can't really make a fair comparison about stability.
- Proprietary connector. WTF Samsung. This is NOT something that you should have copied from apple. Sigh. At least on the PC it's easy to sync between the two devices (though I haven't needed to do that once), I hear on macs it's quite problematic. YMMV
All in all, I'm just floored with the device, and after having a bunch of friends come over an check it out, I think I've probably increased Samsung's sales of this devices by a solid 10.
I bought 2 galaxy Tab 10.1's the day it came out. I am admittedly not the biggest fan of Apple products. I try to stay out of their locked down ecosystem as much as possible as I firmly believe that the user should be able to OWN their products and decide for themselves what they do and what they install on it, and I'm not a fan of willingly handing over my freedom to corporatocracy.
That said, I have to compare the galaxy tab to the only other real tablet on the market, the venerable iPad/iPad 2.
Pros:
- Out of the box, the gTab running Android 3.1 has a pretty impressive array of features
- Multitasking is REALLY well done, in fact, vastly superior to most other implementations, including iOS4.x. The only other real contenders would be the HP slate
- Gchat support is top notch. Unlike iOS, where Apple had to create a whole new proprietary marketing buzzword around "facetime," gchat just works. It works with phones, it works with PCs, you can voice and video chat with other Android 3.1 devices, OR with any computer running gchat. BOOM. No need to install anything special, it just works.
- Widgets: Ok, if you've used android before, these are nothing new. If you're coming from something else, they could be the coolest things you've ever used, or meh. But they've become a lot more powerful regardless. You can now resize widgets, and having, for instance, a gmail widget on your desktop simply makes accessing email so much faster and easier than it is on any other device.
- Live wallpapers. I love them, you might not, but it certainly makes my tablet looks so much more lively than the static wallpapers of yesteryear.
- Battery life is stupendous. But pretty much on par with the ipads. If you're coming from an ipad you'll not notice anything new. If you're coming from a netbook or phone, you're going to be in for a shock. The thing just won't die.
- Beautiful screen. Samsung is one of the leaders in screen tech. They didn't disappoint.
- OMFG it's skinny. Yes, skinnier than the ipad 2. That's a freakin' achievement.
- I own both the white and the metallic grey gtabs. The white is visually "prettier" and has a high gloss smooth finish. The metallic grey is matte and has a texture to it. I prefer the way the metallic grey feels in my hands, but if you're all about looks, the white is very nice.
- Stereo speakers. This was actually a surprise for me. It has speakers that flank the left and right sides (when held in landscape mode). This is definitely a step up above the mono sound coming out of the ipad/ipad2. Volume is actually a lot louder than I had expected from such a svelte device.
- Sync. If you use a lot of google apps... you're going to be in a world of joy. After booting up the device, and merely entering my email and password, I had my contacts, my email, my calendar, my apps, all instantly and seamlessly ported over to the tablet. No need to connect to a computer. Even my music (amazon music) and pictures (picasa) were immediately available. Color me impressed. There is no other device that can do this. iOS5 claims to be bringing this kind of seamlessness over to the iOS world, along with Android 2.2 style notifications, but thank you, I have that right now, and it's sweet.
- Flash. This tablet has it. Apple's don't. If your RSS feed is populated by all sorts of flash based content like mine is, then you'll love it. If you regularly visit restaurant sites, you'll love it. If you want to play Empires and Allies on your tablet (albeit super slowly) you can only do it on this.
Cons:
- Apps. There is no getting around this. It's brand new, the Xoom was a complete flop, and so developers haven't really spent much time porting their apps over to tablet sized screens. Android natively handles scaling of apps much better than iOS, but despite that, there are quite a number of apps that could do with some serious rework to make the layouts more appropriate for the larger real-estate. Also, in general, the quality of apps on android hasn't reached the level on iOS, but that appears to be very quickly changing as developers are now making all of their apps multiplatform. Amazon is also a disgrace in this area as their own android apps (kindle, mp3, appstore) could use some rework on tablet screens. I would love for the kindle app to be updated with the amazingly slick page turning that comes on Google Books. Google even provides the code to do if for free... so Amazon, get your ass in gear and implement that.
- Stability. My android phone can go for months without a reboot. Android 2.2/2.3 are rock solid. Android 3.1 is not there yet. It's not terrible, but there will be times where you'll have a wtf moment when the tablet stalls at the lock screen and you can't seem to unlock it for a few moments, or some apps inexplicably force close. I consider it relatively minor since it's pretty infrequent, but it happens far more than it does on my phone. Not sure how it compares against iOS as even when I casually use iOS, apps freeze and quit on me, and I even had the ipad completely lock up requiring the powerbutton to be held down to reset it. But since I don't use iOS on a day to day basis, I can't really make a fair comparison about stability.
- Proprietary connector. WTF Samsung. This is NOT something that you should have copied from apple. Sigh. At least on the PC it's easy to sync between the two devices (though I haven't needed to do that once), I hear on macs it's quite problematic. YMMV
All in all, I'm just floored with the device, and after having a bunch of friends come over an check it out, I think I've probably increased Samsung's sales of this devices by a solid 10.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)